Booster diversity receiving system usable with cellular booster

ABSTRACT

A diversity receiving apparatus includes first and second antennas and circuitry for selecting one antenna or the other. Control circuitry analyzes signal strength received from the selected antenna and determines when the antennas should be switched.

REFERENCE TO RELATED PATENT APPLICATION

The present patent application is a continuation-in-part of patentapplication Ser. No. 081,120 entitled Booster and filed Aug. 3, 1987 nowU.S. Pat. No. 4,941,200.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The invention pertains to boosters usable in cellular radiotelephonesystems to improve intra-cell coverage. More particularly, the inventionpertains to diversity reception of signals between the booster and thecell site, between the booster and another booster, or between thebooster and a moveable cellular transceiver.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Current cellular system implementations involve the use of a few to theuse of many cells to cover a given geographical area. The cells aredesigned to provide some degree of overlapping coverage. They are alsodesigned to allow reuse of the same channels several cells away (butwithin the same geographical area).

In practice, cellular system cell-site designs do not cover all thedesired coverage areas due to anomalies of RF propagation. For example,a narrow depression in the terrain such as a ravine or along a roadadjacent to a river bed may not have adequate signal coverage due toblockage from nearby terrain.

Another example would be in an underground parking garage, or even inlarge office buildings where larger than normal signal attenuation wouldresult in unacceptable signal levels. Furthermore, cell sites in somecellular systems are not located close enough together, thus resultingin poor coverage areas between the cells.

The addition of new cell sites to remedy such problems is prohibitive inmany cases. This is because the numbers of subscribers in these areasare generally of insufficient quantity to justify the cost of a new cellsite installation.

A low cost alternative solution to this problem is to employ a cellularrepeater or booster near the coverage area in question. Such a repeateris intended to retransmit the channels from a nearby (donor) cell intothe problem area. The retransmitted channels can then be received byappropriate moveable transceivers or mobile units in the area. Likewise,transmissions from mobile units in the problem area can be retransmittedby the booster such that they can be detected by the channel receiversat the donor cell site. One such booster is disclosed in the commonlyassigned patent application hereto, entitled Booster, Ser. No. 081,120filed Aug. 3, 1987. That patent application is hereby incorporatedherein by reference.

Cellular systems employ diversity reception of the signals from themobile to the cell site to overcome the effects of multi-path fading.However, if the signals are amplified by a booster, the multi-pathfading occurs on both the path from the mobile to he booster and thepath from the booster to the cell site. As a result conventional methodsof combining the diversity signals may not be effective.

An effective diversity combiner design must take into account the factthat the multi-path fading on each of these two paths has significantlydifferent characteristics. This is because one path length is fixed andthe other path length is changing rapidly due to vehicle movement. Forexample, the fades on the booster to cell path may experience typicalfading durations of many seconds in contrast with the mobile to boosterfading durations of a few milliseconds when the vehicle is moving.

Switch diversity combining is known. A receiver has two antennas thatare separated in space a distance sufficient to uncorrelate themulti-path fading of the signals on the antennas. Only one antenna isconnected to the receiver at one time. If the received signal fallsbelow a fixed threshold level, the receiver is switched to the otherantenna. This switching algorithm is not optimum for cellular systemsboosters.

On the mobile to booster path, the multi-path fading is very rapid whenthe vehicle is moving, but very slow when the vehicle is stationary. Toselect the best antenna, the combiner must distinguish between these twoconditions. Further, the threshold signal level for switching theantennas should be a function of the received average signal for optimumswitching.

On the fixed path between the booster and the cell site or between twoboosters, the multi-path fading is very slow and may not changesignificantly during the duration of one call. However, the signalreceived by the cell site or booster receiver may vary rapidly becausethe booster receiving signals from the moveable transceiver has notremoved all the multi-path fading caused by the transceiver to boosterpath. The diversity combiner must ignore these rapid fades and selectthe antenna having the best average signal level. At the same time theselection must be rapid compared to the duration of a call.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

An apparatus and method in accordance with the present inventionimplement an improved diversity receiving system. An apparatus inaccordance with the present invention includes first and second antennasusable for receiving electro-magnetic signals. Circuitry coupled to theantennas senses incoming signal levels and selects, in accordance with apredetermined criterion, which of the antennas is to be used.

When the incoming signals are generated by a moving source, thecircuitry repetitively samples a selected parameter value of the signalsbeing detected off of the currently operative antenna. A running averageof measured parameter values is formed.

Antennas are switched if a current sampled signal parameter value fallsbelow, by a predetermined amount, the previously developed runningaverage. In addition, the antennas are switched if the parameter valueof a current sensed signal falls below a predetermined threshold.Finally, the circuitry switches antennas if a predetermined elapsed timehas passed without a switch.

In the event that the signals being received are generated from anon-moving source, the circuitry switches antennas in the event that apredetermined time interval has elapsed and no switch has taken place.After the switch, a measured value of the selected parameter of thenewly sensed signal is compared to the value of the same parametersensed prior to switching antennas. In the event that the prior valueexceeds the current value the antennas are again switched.

Numerous other advantages and features of the present invention willbecome readily apparent from the following detailed description of theinvention and the embodiments thereof, from the claims and from theaccompanying drawings in which the details of the invention are fullyand completely disclosed as a part of this specification.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a portion of a cellular system thatincludes a booster in accordance with the present invention;

FIGS. 2A-2D taken together are a flow diagram of various modes ofoperation of the booster of FIG. 1;

FIG. 3 is a flow diagram illustrating the operation of the booster ofFIG. 1 during reception on the mobile to booster link; and

FIG. 4 is a flow diagram illustrating an alternative mode of operationof the booster of FIG. 1 during reception on the booster to cell sitelink or the booster to booster link.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT

While this invention is susceptible of embodiment in many differentforms, there is shown in the drawing and will be described herein indetail a specific embodiment thereof with the understanding that thepresent disclosure is to be considered as an exemplification of theprinciples of the invention and is not intended to limit the inventionto the specific embodiment illustrated.

FIG. 1 illustrates a system 10 in accordance with the present invention.The system 10 includes a fixed cell site 12 of a conventional varietyused in connection with cellular mobile radio telephone service. Thecell site 12 includes a transmitting and receiving antenna 14.

A booster 16 is illustrated in FIG. 1 in bidirectional communicationwith the cell site 12 and a mobile unit M. The booster 16 includes adirectional transmit and receive antenna 18 which is used to transmitsignals to and receive signals from the cell site 12.

The booster 16 also includes a second antenna 20 for transmittingsignals to and receiving signals from the mobile unit M. The antenna 20can be, but need not be, a directional antenna.

The booster 16 can repeat both voice and control channels in connectionwith a cellular mobile transmission. The repeated channel can berepeated at the same frequency as received. Alternately, the booster 16can shift the transmitted frequency from the received frequency.

The booster 16 includes a plurality of intermediate frequencycommunication paths such as channel paths 22-30 which provide fortransmission of five channels of control or audio in parallel betweenthe mobile unit M and the cell site 12. The booster 16 also includes aplurality of cell site to mobile communication paths 32-40 fortransmitting five channels of control or audio between cell site 12 andthe mobile M.

Each of the intermediate channels 22-30, and 32-40 is identical. Eachshifts an incoming frequency down to a predetermined intermediatefrequency for filtering (each includes a 30 K Hz bandwidth filter) foramplification. Each amplified intermediate frequency signal is thenshifted up to a predetermined transmission frequency. Channel 21 has thesame structure as do each of channels 22-30.

Channels 22-30 and 32-40 are used for repeating incoming signals inaccordance with a predetermined interior discussed subsequently. Channel21 is used only for measuring incoming signals from mobil M and fortransmitting hand-off messages to the mobile M.

Signals from the cell site 12 transmitted to the booster 16 and detectedat antenna 18 pass through duplexer 50 and enter multi-coupler 52. Themulticoupler 52 provides RF amplification of low level signals. Outputfrom the multi-coupler 52, on lines 52a-e, provides input to thecommunication paths 32-40 which, as discussed subsequently, areimplemented as intermediate frequency transmission paths.

Output from each of the paths 32-40 is amplified in RF power outputamplifiers 54a-e. Amplified outputs from the amplifiers 54a-e arecombined in a high power lossless combiner 56. Alternatively, separateantennas may be employed for each RF power amplifier, or a very highpower linear amplifier using distortion cancelling techniques may beused with a single antenna. The output from the combiner 56, on a singleline 56a, is coupled to a duplexer 58. Output from the duplexer 58 isthen transmitted via the antenna 20 to the mobile M.

Incoming signals received from the mobile unit M at the antenna 20 arecoupled via the duplexer 58 to multi-coupler 60. Outputs from themulti-coupler 60 drive the intermediate frequency communication paths22-30. Outputs from the paths 22-30 are combined in a five way combiner62. The combined output from the five way combiner 62 is amplified inthe linear amplifier 64. The output from the amplifier 64 provides aninput to the duplexer 50.

Output from the duplexer 50 is coupled via the directional antenna 18 tothe cell site 12. The intermediate frequency communication paths 21-30and 32-40 operate under control of a stored program control unit 66.

Mobiles that are driving into the area served by the booster 16 aremonitored for several scans thereof to determine the signal level trendbefore boosting or retransmission of the mobile is attempted. As aresult, erroneous boosting of channels due to momentarily strong mobilesignals can be minimized.

A specific transmission path can be provided for the control channel ofthe cell site 12 to allow mobile call originations or terminations to becompleted for those mobiles which are not currently active but which arein the vicinity of the booster 16. The transmission path for the controlchannel may be purposely offset to provide F1-F2 repeater operation. Forthe same mobiles, an "action" threshold level is provided to allow quickresponse in setting up a boosted transmission path for a new call. This"action" threshold level is generally higher than the minimum thresholdlevel. A signal exceeding this level is flagged for immediate action atthe end of a scan. The mobile will transmit on the channel assigned bythe cell site 12 for a maximum of five seconds without the presence of acorrect supervisory audio tone being detected by the booster 16.

If the mobile signal exceeds the "action" threshold, a boostedtransmission path will be placed on that channel within a couple ofseconds. If the signal is below that threshold but above the minimumthreshold, a boosted transmission path may be assigned within severalseconds.

Weaker mobile signals that approach the minimum threshold will generallybe in an area where some coverage is provided directly from the cellsite 12. This provides adequate time for the booster 16 to average thereadings and determine that a new channel is to be boosted.

Each of the intermediate frequency booster channels 21-30 and 32-40 isimplemented with microprocessor controlled step down and step upfrequency synthesizers. The use of two frequency synthesizers permitsthe offset of the control channel to another nearby control channel, aswell as the offsetting of the voice channels. Channel 21 is implementedusing similar circuitry. The above comments also apply with respect tothe transmission paths 32 through 40 which are used for the purpose ofboosting signals from the cell site 12 to the mobile M.

The stored program control unit 66 includes an 8031 Intelmicroprocessor. The processor provides overall control for the booster16. It communicates with the other circuitry in the booster 16 viainterface circuitry. The control unit 66 also includes a 10 kilobit datademodulator and a 6 kHZ supervisory audio tone (SAT) demodulator. Thedemodulator includes circuitry for decoding the 10 kilobit data streamwhich is utilized in the cellular system and for measuring which of theSAT frequencies is being transponded by the cellular mobile unit such asthe mobile unit M.

The control unit 66 is utilized for maintaining signal level history forprocessing purposes as well as for controlling the frequencysynthesizers, such as the synthesizers in each intermediate frequencybranch 21-30, and 32-40. It is also used for setting the signal gainthrough each path as well as for measuring the received signal levels oneach channel and for carrying out diagnostic and parameter settingfunctions.

A flow diagram, FIGS. 2A-2D, describes the sequence of events that takesplace in determining candidate channels for boosting. All the channelsof the cell site 12 are scanned. If the measured signal level from amobile on any of the cell site channels exceeds a minimum presetthreshold and also has the correct SAT frequency, that channel numberand its signal level are recorded. A running history of the signallevels of the various mobiles that are active is maintained in a table.At the end of each channel-set scan the data in the table are analyzedto rank the signals by level. A determination is then made as to whichsignals are to be boosted or retransmitted.

The booster 10 of FIG. 1 includes additional hardware to implement thediversity receiving capability in accordance with the present invention.In addition to the antenna 20 a second antenna 19 is provided fordiversity reception and also usable for hand off message transmission tomobile units. The antenna 19 is coupled to an antenna port of duplexer59. Output from the duplexer 59 is coupled to a receiver multicoupler61.

Parallel outputs from the receiver multicoupler 61 on a plurality oflines 61a through 61f are coupled by a plurality of radio frequencyswitches 63a through 63f to inputs to the intermediate frequencychannels 21 through 30. Each of the radio frequency switches receives asa second input a corresponding signal line from the receivermulticoupler 60, lines 60a through 60f.

Each of the radio frequency switches, such as the switch 63a functionsunder the control of a microprocessor contained in the correspondingintermediate frequency block, such as the block 21. A command line, suchas 21a, from the microprocessor signals the switch 63a as to which inputis to be selected. The radio frequency switches can each be implementedusing forward or reverse biased PIN radio frequency switching diodes.

In addition, the output of intermediate frequency channel 21 is coupledby a power amplifier 65 to the transmit input port of the duplexer 59.The amplifier 65 can be used to provide handoff message signals fortransmission to the moveable transceivers such as portable units or themobile unit M in the vicinity of the booster 10. Intermediate frequencychannel or path 21 is used to either measure input signal levels fromthe moveable transceiver M or to transmit the previously noted handoffmessages.

The booster 10 can also be equipped with a second directional antenna 17directed toward the cell site 12. The second directional antenna 17 canbe used to implement an optional diversity function with respect totransmissions from the cell site 12. The antenna 17 is coupled to an RFinput port of multicoupler 51.

Output from multicoupler 51, on a plurality of lines 51a through 51e isin turn coupled to an input of a respective one of a plurality of RFswitches 53a through 53d. The switches 53a through 53d are identical toeach of the switches 63a through 63f.

Output from the multicoupler 52 provides a second input to each of theswitches 53a through 53f. Each of the radio frequency switches 53athrough 53f functions under the control of a microprocessor in one ofthe respective intermediate frequency channels 32 through 40. Forexample, a command line 40a between the intermediate frequency channel40 and the radio frequency switch 53d causes that switch to select aninput from either multicoupler 52 or multicoupler 51.

As an alternate to communicating directly with a mobile, such as themobile M, the booster 10 can be used for the purpose of communicatingwith a second booster 10a. The booster 10a can in turn communicatedirectly with a mobile M'. The booster 10a can be implemented with twoantennas, 19a, 20a for purposes of implementing diversity receivingfunction with respect to the mobile units, such as the mobile unit M'.

A single antenna 18a can be implemented at the booster 10a for thepurpose of communicating with the booster 10. Alternately, a diversityantenna 17a, corresponding to the diversity receiving antenna 17, can beimplemented at the booster 10a for the purpose of providing a diversityreceiving function therein with respect to transmissions from booster10.

As noted previously, fading on the mobile-booster path is very rapidwhen the vehicle is moving but very slow when the vehicle is stationary.On the other hand, on the fixed path between boosters or between abooster and a cell site, the fading is very slow and may not changesignificantly during a given call. In this instance it is important toignore any high speed fading and select an antenna having the bestaverage signal value.

FIG. 3 is a flow diagram of the steps of a method in accordance with thepresent invention for antenna switching on the mobile to booster path.The method implemented in the flow diagram of FIG. 3 is carried out bythe respective controlling microprocessor in each of the intermediatefrequency blocks 21-30. Such a microprocessor can be implemented, forexample, as a 63CO5 type microprocessor.

The following abbreviations are used on the flow diagram of FIG. 3:

RSSI--present received signal level (dBm)

So--present sample signal strength (dBm)

So'--signal strength of last sample

Sa--average signal strength

Sd1--hysteresis threshold 1 (dB)--on order of 10 dB

Sn--receiver noise floor (dBm)

Sd2--hysteresis threshold 2 (dB)--on order of 4 dB

Ts--time since last antenna switch

Tp--maximum antenna switch period--on order of 1 second

In an initial step 200 the respective microprocessor, such as in theintermediate frequency channel 21, calculates and stores, every fewmicroseconds, typically 250 microseconds, the average signal received onthe selected antenna 19 or 20. Signal values are averaged over a longerpredetermined period of time, typically a half second or so. In additionthe time interval since the last switch of antennas is recorded.

Subsequently, in a step 202 the microprocessor determines whether or notthe most recently sampled signal level off of the currently selectedantenna is a predetermined number of dB below the precalculated averagesignal level. If so the antenna is switched. If antenna 19 had beenselected antenna 20 will now be selected.

If the currently measured signal value is not the pre-determined numberof dB below the average signal value then, in a step 204, the processordetermines whether or not the most recently measured signal value isless than a predetermined threshold value. If so the antennas are againinterchanged. If not, the processor in a step 206 determines whether ornot the time elapsed since the last interchange of antennas exceeds apredetermined period, typically one (1) second or so. If not theantennas are not interchanged and after a predetermined time interval,on the order of 250 μsec, the processor repeats the calculations.

If the antennas have not been interchanged during the last predeterminedperiod, typically one second, the microprocessor in a step 208interchanges the antenna and resets the time duration indicator to zero(0). In a step 210 the processor determines whether or not the presentmeasured signal strength, after the antennas have been interchanged isgreater than the previously measured signal strength. If so the newlyselected antenna continues to be used. If not, the previously antenna isselected again.

The method of FIG. 3 operates independently in the controlmicroprocessor of each of the channels 21-30. Hence, each such channelcan independently switch between antenna 19 and antenna 20.

FIG. 4 is a flow diagram illustrating the steps carried out by themicroprocessor in the immediate frequency blocks 21-30 when the booster10 is repeating signals generated by another booster 10a.

In addition, the method of FIG. 4 illustrates steps carried out bychannels 32-40 when repeating signals, received via antenna 17 orantenna 18, from the cell site 12. In contradistinction to the flowdiagram of FIG. 3 when the booster 10 is repeating signals from anotherbooster 10a or the cell site 12, a longer predetermined period of timeTp, typically 60 seconds or so, causes the microprocessor to select theantenna with the strongest signal every minute or so.

Except for Tp, symbols used on the flow diagram of FIG. 4 have the samedefinitions as noted above with respect to the flow diagram of FIG. 3.Ts can be initially set to 60 in a step 214. Ts is compared to a presetvalue of Tp, on the order of 60 seconds, in a step 216. After a delay218 on the order of 250 μsec, the process can be repeated.

Each of the channels 21-30 or 32-40 carries out the above describedanalysis and antenna switching function independently of every otherchannel.

From the foregoing, it will be observed that numerous variations andmodifications may be effected without departing from the spirits andscope of the novel concept of the invention. It is to be understood thatno limitation with respect to the specific apparatus illustrated hereinis intended or should be inferred. It is, of course, intended to coverby the appended claims all such modifications as fall within the scopeof the claims.

What is claimed is:
 1. An apparatus usable in a cellular booster forselecting between at least first and second antennas usable to receivesignals from a moveable unit comprising:means for detecting signals fromthe first antenna; means for detecting signals from the second antenna;switching means, coupled to said detecting means, for selecting thefirst antenna or the second antenna; means, coupled to said switchingmeans, for repetitively measuring a selected parameter of a signalreceived off of said selected antenna; means, coupled to said measuringmeans, for forming a running average value of said selected parameter inresponse to a predetermined number of prior measurements; means, coupledto said measuring and said forming means, for comparing a present valueof said selected parameter to said average value including means forgenerating an electrical signal in response to results of saidcomparison; and means, responsive to said electrical signal, fordetermining if said other antenna should be selected with saiddetermining means including: means for detecting if said present valueof said selected parameter exceeds a predetermined threshold includingmeans for generating a threshold exceeded indicium in response theretoand threshold activated means, responsive to said indicium for selectingsaid other antenna.
 2. An apparatus for selecting between at least firstand second antennas comprising:means for detecting signals from thefirst antenna; means for detecting signals from the second antenna;switching means, coupled to said detecting means, for selecting thefirst antenna or the second antenna; means, coupled to said switchingmeans, for repetitively measuring a selected parameter of a signalreceived off of said selected antenna; means, coupled to said measuringmeans, for forming a running average value of said selected parameter inresponse to a predetermined number of prior measurements; means, coupledto said measuring and said forming means, for comparing a present valueof said selected parameter to said average value including means forgenerating an electrical signal in response to results of saidcomparison; means, responsive to said electrical signal, for determiningif said other antenna should be selected said determining meansincluding: means for detecting if said present value of said selectedparameter exceeds a predetermined threshold including means forgenerating a threshold exceeded indicium in response thereto andthreshold activated means, responsive to said indicium for selectingsaid other antenna.
 3. A method of selecting between at least first andsecond antennas comprising:detecting signals from the first antenna;detecting signals from the second antenna; selecting the first antennaor the second antenna; repetitively measuring, after the selecting step,a selected parameter of a signal received off of the selected antenna;forming a running average value of said selected parameter in responseto a predetermined number of prior measurements; comparing, after theforming step, a present value of the selected parameter to the averagevalue and switching antennas if the present value is less than theaverage value; and if the antennas were not switched in the comparingstep, determining if the other antenna should be selected by detectingif the present value of the selected parameter exceeds a predeterminedthreshold including generating a threshold exceeded indicium in responsethereto and selecting the other antenna in response to said indicium. 4.A booster including a diversity receiving system and usable in a radiotelephone system to enhance communications between a fixed transceiverand a moveable transceiver;a plurality of intermediate frequencycommunication means each having an input and an output; first and secondelectro-magnetic signal receiving means associated with the movabletransceiver and third and fourth electro-magnetic signal receiving meansassociated with the fixed transceiver; a plurality of selecting meanswith each of said selecting means coupled to an input of a respectiveone of said communication means with said first and second receivingmeans each coupled to each of said selecting means; and a plurality ofcontrol means, with one of said control means included in each saidcommunication means, coupled to a respective one of said selectingmeans, for analyzing a selected parameter of an electro-magnetic signalreceived from one of said first or second receiving means and fordetermining if said selecting means associated with said respectivecommunication means should be switched to said other receiving means. 5.A system as in claim 4 with each said control means including means foroperating, at least in part, said respective communication means and forexecuting said analyzing and said determining functions independently ofevery other member of said plurality of control means.
 6. A system as inclaim 4 including means for transmission coupled to outputs of at leastsome of said communication means.
 7. A system as in claim 6 including anantenna, usable at least for transmission, coupled to said transmissionmeans.